• Survivor 51 · Episode 8

A Hero in the Making: Why fans love Kristin Flickinger

How Kristin overcame the anti-super fan bias and became a fan favorite

One of few certainties in the permanent uncertainty era of the show is that super fans of Survivor do not typically like watching other super fans on the show. Super fans are self inserts for fans who want to play the game themselves, and anyone who wants to play wants to imagine themselves being the cool, calm, collected, charismatic fan favorite who plays a perfect winning game, but because most big fans of the show are at least a little nerdy, and very excited to be there, they tend to present as a bit over eager, or “cringe” (the greatest offense known to man). Nobody wants to be laughed at, and when super fans become the butt of the joke, aspiring future contestants resent them for it, because they fear they will face the same fate. But if ever there has been a super fan on the show, it is Kristin Flickinger, who has been applying since the very beginning, and not only managed to avoid the fans’ ire, but became a beloved fan favorite as soon as the season premiered. And she managed to do it while bucking the stereotype.

Kristin fits into an archetype that we have not seen often on the show in recent years. While super fans are always knowledgeable about the show’s history, and different strategic elements of the game, they are not known for being particularly outdoorsy or good at managing the camp life aspect of the game. Kristin feels in many ways to be reminiscent of Gretchen Cordy from Survivor Borneo. She is incredibly knowledgeable about plant life, and resources around the island that can be used to one’s benefit. She is a skilled firemaker, negotiator, and, as she informed Mike during a miscommunication at the merge vote, she knows how to be chill. She has the vibe of the friend who will show up at your house with a toolbox knowing exactly how to fix a problem when it arises. If the touchy subjects challenge came back this season, Kristin almost certainly would have received every vote when the players were asked which player they’d most want to be stranded on an island with. She’s like Linda Liddle, the character played by Rachel McAdams in Send Help (a must watch for any Survivor fan— especially considering the references to the show in the film), but without the lack of social grace or vindictiveness. If not for Sharonda being a doctor, she almost certainly would have been the favorite answer for the “which contestant would you trust with your life” question as well.

She was just as excited to be there as any other super fan, if not more, considering how long she’d been applying, but we see that excitement expressed as quiet gratitude, rather than the frenetic excitement of younger super fans who (understandably) can hardly contain themselves. If there’s any consolation in knowing that the show deprived us of her presence for so many years, it’s that her maturity at forty-nine may have played a role in her demeanor and approach to the game, which was a major factor in viewers falling in love with her. She is competent, confident, and above all else, she’s just cool, and that makes it near impossible to dislike her.

While there have been many passionate fans who have been cast on the show over the years, only certain types of players are remembered for being one. Michael Yerger, a male model who played on Survivor Ghost Island at only eighteen years old, was a very big fan of the show, and played like it. While he often came off as more quiet and introverted on the show, he had no qualms about using his idol in a dramatic fashion to try to save his alliance when they were at a numbers disadvantage after the swap, rather than saving it to protect only himself, and was voted out of the game after the merge for being the biggest threat in the game for the majority alliance. In a game where many players were harshly judged for trying to integrate with the majority, rather than opposing them, he chose to fight against them until the very end, choosing the riskier path knowing it was his only chance of winning. It was revealed post season that Wendell Holland made a very convincing fake idol that Michael was able to quickly identify as a fake only because he knew the twist of the season was that all of the advantages were previously seen on the show, and he was confident the fake had never been seen on the show before. He even recently shared online that he has been offered opportunities to do other shows, and declined, because he was loyal to Survivor. Even so, he is virtually never recognized as a super fan who has played the game, because he is so conventionally good looking, and does not come off as a particularly nerdy person. Unlike Michael, Kristin does come off very nerdy in some ways (proposing a thumb war in the premiere being the biggest tell), to enough of a degree that validates her super fan status, but not to the extent of giving viewers the second hand embarrassment that they seem to so often experience when watching super fans play. She comes across more as the person who’d be kicking back with a beer at a party than spending an hour talking a polite person’s ear off about the show despite them never having seen it (something that I have, of course, never been guilty of doing a single time in my life). There is, very depressingly, something to be said about how fans often judge contestants who very outwardly show signs of struggling with anxiety disorders and/or neurodivergence much more cruelly than those who don’t, but that is a conversation for another day.

The most beloved heroes in history, in both fiction and non-fiction, are determined, fierce, intelligent problem solvers. They are people who continue to get back up no matter how many times they get knocked down, who feel fear like anyone else, but look that fear in the eyes, and do the scary thing, no matter how badly the odds are stacked against them. It takes a very special person to have the wherewithal to continue to apply for a spot over and over for a quarter of a century despite facing constant rejection— and to continue on in the game with a broken foot. It would be very easy for someone in Kristin’s position to play the game from a place of fear and panic, after years of pent up energy from working so hard to get on the show, thinking about what one would do with that chance if they finally got it. But Kristin always came across as being very in control. Even when she got emotional, she never had an outburst, and always thought clearly when making decisions. Although the game did not go as she wanted, as she was devastatingly sent home alongside fellow super fan Kilby (who played exactly the kind of fearless game that fans claim they want to see, but was unfortunately not embraced by the fans to the same extent), with only one vote cast against them, she approached the game from start to finish in the way that every fan wants to imagine themselves doing. She was the kind of player hopeful applicants want to be, and the type of ally anyone would want to have. And, like all of the most beloved contestants who came before her, she came across as incredibly authentic. Just by being herself in front of the camera, she managed to be an inspiration not just for women, “older” people (by Survivor standards), the LGBTQ community, and long time applicants who are struggling to keep hope alive, but to all people from all walks of life.

At a point in time when the future of our planet feels incredibly uncertain, leaving some feeling more pessimistic and hopeless than ever, and with AI being forced down the public’s throat at every angle, strongly encouraging us to offload our thinking to a machine, seeing someone as resourceful and determined as Kristin on our screens provides some encouragement that maybe there is some hope for the future of humanity after all. While it is nice to be reminded that there are people out there who are exactly the types anyone would want by our side in a worst case, apocalyptic scenario, it is also a needed reminder that many of us are capable of becoming that person ourselves. It is often said that reality television stars should not be viewed as role models, and I certainly agree with the notion that we should not be putting people we do not know on pedestals, but there are many benefits to being inspired by some aspects of the personalities we see on screen— I personally was inspired to start lifting weights after seeing Natalie Anderson crush challenges on the Edge of Extinction during Winners at War, while her fellow castaways watched her in awe, and I became a stronger, more competent, and confident woman as a result. If viewers can find inspiration in watching Kristin achieve her dream after so many years of rejection, while using her knowledge of her environment and the plants it contains to the benefit of her and her tribe, then it will at the very least leave the world a little less worse off than it was before.

Most of us will not have the opportunity to save the world in a dramatic fashion, like Katniss Everdeen or Luke Skywalker. Oftentimes, everyday heroes are those who inspire us to be a little better than we were before, in both big and small ways, and considering her overwhelming popularity throughout the season, there is no doubt that Kristin did exactly that. At the very least, as far as reality tv personalities go, her presence on the season not only gave fans someone to root for, but someone to draw inspiration from after the credits roll. And while that may not be as great of a consolation prize as those involving hard cash, it is still something worth celebrating.

We donate 10% of our advertising profits to philanthropic causes. Click here to earn votes and vote on which charity we should donate to next.